: Reviewers from Tokyo Gazette praise the episode for humanizing Kisame Hoshigaki, shifting his image from a "ruthless monster" to a deeply loyal shinobi.
: Fan reactions on Reddit emphasize that Kisame's choice to sacrifice himself to protect Akatsuki secrets was a "badass" and fitting end for a member of the Seven Ninja Swordsmen. Naruto Shippuuden (Dub) Episode 251
: While highly rated, some long-term viewers found that the lack of prior world-building for the Uzumaki clan slightly dampened the impact of the wider narrative arc this episode sits within. : Reviewers from Tokyo Gazette praise the episode
: The animation of the final confrontation and Kisame's ultimate technique is noted for being "better to look at than the usual stuff" in this arc. Critical Perspectives Naruto Shippuuden (Dub) Episode 251