Shortly after its release, "Cookie" faced scrutiny over its lyrics. Some listeners and linguists expressed concern that the term "cookie" could be interpreted as a double entendre in English, which they felt was inappropriate given that the members were minors at the time.
The song was praised for its sophisticated production and earworm hook. It performed exceptionally well on Korean digital charts, helping NewJeans achieve a "Perfect All-Kill" with their debut EP—a rare feat for a new group. Critics often highlight "Cookie" as a key example of the "New Jersey Club" influence that defines much of the group's early discography. Controversy NewJeans (뉴진스) - Cookie гЂЊAudioгЂЌ
: Successfully charted, cementing their international appeal early on. Shortly after its release, "Cookie" faced scrutiny over
: The lyrics use a "baking" metaphor to describe the effort put into a crush, comparing the song's addictive quality to a fresh-baked cookie. Critical Reception and Success It performed exceptionally well on Korean digital charts,