Reviewers generally find the episode "pretty good overall" but note its lack of "umph" for a season finale. It is often categorized as "filler" because the characters and plot points (like the ice man himself) do not return in future episodes. However, it is praised for:
: Helping to solidify the boys' personalities before the show's more plot-heavy era. [S2E18] Prehistoric Ice Man
: The episode features a memorable appearance by a caricature of Steve Irwin (The Crocodile Hunter). Cartman’s imitation of Irwin—including his obsession with "sticking his finger up its butthole"—remains one of the more quotable bits from the early seasons. Reviewers generally find the episode "pretty good overall"
The story follows Stan, Kyle, Cartman, and Kenny as they discover a man frozen in ice. While Stan and Kyle argue over what to name him— or Steve —the man is taken to a government facility. In a classic South Park twist, "prehistoric" is revealed to be the year 1996, and the "ice man" is simply a guy who has been frozen for 32 months. Key Highlights : The episode features a memorable appearance by
: The satire of 1996 as a "prehistoric" era—complete with Ace of Base music and a lifestyle focused on the movie Independence Day —is a clever jab at how quickly pop culture dates itself. Critical Reception
: This episode is significant for introducing the first major rift between the two best friends. Their petty argument over the ice man's name escalates into a genuine falling out, providing a rare (at the time) look at the friction in their friendship.