[s2e9] Slap Bet -

While the episode is overwhelmingly popular, some fans on Reddit have spent years debating the fairness of Lily's rulings as the "Slap Bet Commissioner".

“The absurdity of a slap bet is amusing in itself but throw in Marshall and Barney and you have a formula for entertainment gold.” WordPress.com · 12 years ago [S2E9] Slap Bet

“The reveal is both crazy and brilliantly executed, which I thought elevated Robin's character to a higher level.” Reddit · r/HIMYM While the episode is overwhelmingly popular, some fans