is the ninth episode of the fifth season of The Office (Episode 81 overall), originally airing on November 20, 2008. Written by Mindy Kaling and directed by Jason Reitman, it centers on Michael Scott’s irrational, visceral reaction to the return of his HR nemesis, Toby Flenderson. Plot Summary
Reviewers at The AV Club noted that while the "caprese salad" plot was somewhat over-the-top, the emotional payoff of Jim buying the house for Pam was disarmingly sweet. Critics also praised the "darkly comedic" exploration of Michael's hatred, with IMDb reviewers highlighting the episode's rhythmic editing and tension. "The Office" Frame Toby (TV Episode 2008) - IMDb [S5E8] Frame Toby
: In a major series milestone, Jim surprises Pam by revealing he bought his parents' old house—complete with shag carpeting and a creepy clown painting—to be their future home. Key Moments & Quotes is the ninth episode of the fifth season
: Pam becomes frustrated by a "saucy mess" in the office microwave and leaves an anonymous note, which the rest of the staff finds condescending and "holier-than-thou". Critics also praised the "darkly comedic" exploration of
: Michael discovers Toby is back from Costa Rica and has been working in the annex for an entire week without Michael noticing.
: Michael describes trying to be friends with Toby as "trying to be friends with an evil snail".
: After David Wallace explains that Toby can only be fired "for cause," Michael and Dwight attempt to manufacture a crime. After failed attempts at inciting violence or sexual harassment, Michael buys "marijuana" for $500 from warehouse workers (which turns out to be caprese salad in a bag) and plants it in Toby's desk.